Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Brad Smith's avatar

A nation has hit it's peak when it starts to analyze itself.

Some groups will look to the glorious past, others will demand we move to a new brighter future and demand we forget the past. Many people are just sure it's all shit and act accordingly.

The one thing they have in common is the belief that Today Sucks.

Authors like Nietzsche, Sir John Glubb and Alfred North Whitehead all wrote about this phenomena.

Glubb said that a nation of hero's will eventually end up becoming a nation full of thinkers, who are no longer capable of acting.

Whitehead said "Civilization advances by extending the number of important operations which we can perform without thinking about them." Once we have to stop and think through every little thing we are powerless to change anything for the better.

Nietzsche said nations that over-analyze are doomed, only nations that can act without a constant historical evaluation are free to act.

We are in "late state Bureaucracy", we analyze and micromanage but that's all we are capable of doing. The thinkers think, but that's all they do, they don't act. The dreamers dream, but again, that's all they do. The grumblers grumble and get nasty and rude, but that's also all they know how to do. The Bureaucrats actually rule, because they have been granted the power of the purse, while everyone else is paralyzed by doubt.

This is where we are today; we are besieged by Bureaucracy, which is never efficient or pleasant. Bureaucrats love the status quo, it's their lifeblood. Bureaucrats advance nothing of true value because they exist to exist and that's their only reason for being. A a nation run by Bureaucrats and abstract thinkers, who are incapable of action, will suffer from a slow decline until eventually even great empires are only a shadow of themselves.

Where is there room for rugged individualism in a nation run by abstract thinkers and bureaucrats? Why even be polite or efficient when the Bureaucrats are running the show, they are the opposite of polite and efficient and they set the tone.

It all trickles down and that's what we are seeing.

This is life under the thumb of Bureaucracy and it's what comes from thinking rather than acting, it comes from following rules made by Bureaucrats themselves, rather than from citizens who are trying to optimize liberty and prosperity. And no group of Bureaucrats is ever capable of real change, not if there are more than a dozen of them arguing about any given topic, which there always is.

I'm going to coin a phrase here, "Trickle Down Bureaucracy", which explains exactly were we are today. That doesn't just include government Bureaucracy either, it extends into the corporate world which has also been taken over by them.

How does a nation full of abstract thinkers and Bureaucrats better itself? It doesn't and that's the truth we are seeing today.

Tim McGraw's avatar

Great essay! When the Southerners lose their hospitality, America is in big trouble.

Yes, it's the quiet small town life for my wife and me as well. Most everything is delivered. What happens when that system fails?

Our idea of prepping is having emergency whisky, and plenty of Brut and Amstel Light on hand, as well as enough food and water for a couple of weeks. After that...well, who cares?

We are glad we don't have grandchildren.

We do our best to be friendly at the stores and the bank. I crack jokes and hand out shamrocks for St. Patrick's Day. Some people respond in a positive way. There is hope and the American Spirit still out there in the Remnant.

Thanks again for the essay.

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?